7 Comments

June 27th, 2008 @8:42 am  

Hmmm, about the only reason from your list of 5 that carries any validity is the one about community. Yes Ubuntu has more users, and some/many of the users seem to have a possibly better attitude about helping people.

Almost all distros of any note these days has a live cd. Many have multiple flavours of live cds (like ubuntu).

By the same token, most popular distros have made great strides in user-friendly installation. Perhaps Ubuntu deserves some credit for leading the way on this, I do’nt know. But it’s no longer unique, or a point of superiority.

As you point out out Ubuntu is debian-based, and as such uses apt, which is generally acknowledged to be about the best there is for managing software post-installation. However, Ubuntu is not the only debian-based distro, is it?

Ubuntu just works? I think you’ll find they’ve got a forum chock full of people needing help, because it doesn’t “just work” for all people, all the time, on all hardware. Just like all the other OS’s out there. For me, that’s what makes tinkering with linux fun, and sometimes frustrating…

mygif
Raseel Said,
June 27th, 2008 @8:42 am  

Well,of all the reasons you mention I think Community Support is the only compelling reason worth considering. All the other 4 reasons are now almost a pre-requisite for most mainstream Distros and if you see Distros like Fedora , OpenSuse, PCLinuxOS, Mandriva … (the list goes on), these 4 are already present.
Having said that , I’m a self-proclaimed Ubuntu fanboy and I think it rocks !!!

mygif
bjb_nyj101 Said,
June 27th, 2008 @10:07 am  

Upgrading to a new release is not always as easy as you make it seem. Just visit the ubuntu forums after a new release and see the all the people that have hosed their systems trying to do a
‘dist-upgrade’. If it works, its great. But if it doesn;t , a new user is in a world of trouble.

mygif
Donald Said,
June 27th, 2008 @2:47 pm  

Wow. I think the author fails to understand that there are many distributions because there are many opinions about what constitutes “best.” I prefer something that has good performance over something that is simple to install or “just works” (which Ubuntu quite often doesn’t).

I recently ditched Ubuntu for Arch Linux because of the amount of bloat it contains trying to work everywhere for everyone. Additionally, it’s much easier to install software from source and the packages are more cutting edge in Arch. I recommend Ubuntu to almost everyone I meet who is interested in Linux because it is one of the all-around easiest distributions for new users.

However, to say that because something is easiest it is the best is like saying checkers is better than chess. It’s not true for all people.

mygif
Adam Kane Said,
June 27th, 2008 @2:54 pm  

Donald,

I’m certainly not failing to realize that there are many distributions available. You’re right, beauty and “the best” is in the eye of the beholder. This article contains my own opinions of why I think Ubuntu is superior to all of the other distributions available today.

With that being said, I haven’t really suggested that Ubuntu is the best. I’m simply making points as to why it is better than what is available today for the average, or new Linux user.

Thank you for your comments and input, I appreciate all constructive user feedback.

Cheers! :)

mygif
Uburocks Said,
June 27th, 2008 @7:21 pm  

As a former Ubuntu fanboy I can almost agree with you on this.

On the surface I think Ubuntu is great. It’s stable and there’s a ton of software available for free. The downside is hardware support and even flash. I have scoured the internet and tried every “solution”, but I have not been able to get the same online experience with Ubuntu that I do with Vista.

My suggestion to Ubuntu would be to not be so adamant about releasing a new version every 6 months with the same bugs as the previous versions. Instead, hammer out the problems and put out an OS that truly is workable “straight outta the box”.

mygif
Lord Vayder Said,
June 29th, 2008 @4:34 am  

I happen to agree with everything you said. Ubuntu has been the ONLY distro that works for me. I tried Mandriva - barely configurable, didn’t have near any many other working aspects. Tried 2 other distros and they didn’t work at all.

Ubuntu is awesome - it is fast, good looking (because you can install anything to get your look), and never has failed me. Plus it installs easily within about 30 minutes each upgrade. Thanks, Mr. Shuttleworth and Canonical.

mygif

Random Post

Leave Your Comments Below

Please Note: All comments will be hand modified by our authors so any unsuitable comments will be removed and you comments will be appreared after approved